Zhou Qianxin didn't answer directly, only glanced at the four of them.
It was the female intern who stood up and said: "It should not be wrong that the victim had a slight life reaction from the restraint injuries caused by being tied to a heavy object and sinking to the bottom of the water, and the conclusion of the autopsy also pointed to drowning, although the drowning reaction is called a normal situation." ” "From this point of view, although the conclusion is a bit beyond imagination, the victim should have drowned, and to be specific, drowning during the near-death period, resulting in death."
Zhou Qianxin asked expressionlessly: "Are you sure?"
After hesitating for a moment, the girl nodded firmly: "Sure" "What about the two of you?"
The other two boys looked at each other and nodded.
"That's right."
Zhou Qianxin sighed: "It's just that you obviously had doubts about this before the autopsy began, why don't you dare to say it?"
"As a forensic doctor, when judging the cause of death of the victim, he must be thorough and must not be negligent, even if it is beyond imagination and bizarre possibility, as long as there is factual evidence to support it, and it cannot be proven, this hypothesis should be put forward, understand?"
"Autopsy work, many times, is the application of the elimination method to prove the process of one by one, if the corresponding hypothesis cannot be put forward, how to prove the no, to exclude him" "And after the autopsy, it is clear that all the morphological and pathological features of the organs point to drowning, so shouldn't it be concluded that the deceased was drowned?"
"You remember that forensic science is essentially a forensic discipline, and it must follow the basic requirements of evidence-based medicine, that is, based on evidence-based practice, everything is based on evidence, and it speaks by evidence, rather than relying on one's own subjective experience and subjective judgment."
"To put it simply, subjective experience, speculation and judgment only provide a direction and focus for the autopsy work, but if it conflicts with the evidence, you must adjust your guess as soon as possible to draw conclusions that are consistent with the facts and understand" "Understood," the four said in unison.
Zhou Qianxin looked at Xiao Hua again: "Xiao Hua, you answer me now, why do you have to spend time and effort to do this autopsy when the cause of the victim's death is clear."
He snorted twice, hurriedly organized the language, and said: "Because, the so-called clarity, in fact, is only my subjective speculation, and in fact, the victim did not die of injury, hemorrhagic shock at all, but from mechanical asphyxiation caused by drowning." ” "Although the victim may have died clinically even if he had not dumped the body, in the final analysis, he died from drowning, i.e., the death of the victim caused by the robbers' act of throwing the body into the river."
"Therefore, proceeding from the objective facts and logical relationship and the practice of judicial appraisal, the person who dumped the body must bear the main direct responsibility for the victim's death and is the direct murderer."
"Although the rest of the robbers, although they also caused the death of the victim to a large extent, they are considered to be one of the important perpetrators, but the responsibility they bear should still be different from that of the person who dumped the body, and it is secondary indirect responsibility."
"After all, to a certain extent, the victim is only near death when he drowns, and if he seeks medical attention in time, there is still a logical objective possibility of rescue, even if the possibility is very small, even if the gangsters do not have the subjective will to send the victim to medical treatment at all."
"In other words, the conclusions reached by our forensic doctors will greatly affect and even influence the culpability of the robbers."
Zhou Qianxin nodded with satisfaction: "Well, that's the point." ” "You don't really have to talk about it, though.
To put it simply, our task is to identify the cause of the victim's death and to distinguish between the logical direct and indirect perpetrators and those responsible for the fact that the victim was injured or killed. ” Xiaohua scratched his head and muttered, "But Mr.
Zhou, why do I think what you said is more complicated" Zhou Qianxin was speechless, and then waved her hand: "Okay, this class is here, it's late, let's go back and rest."
After seeing the interns leave, Zhou Qianxin roughly examined the corpse and various organs, confirmed that they were correct, and then returned the organs to their original positions, sutured them up, wiped them clean, and carried them into the freezer.
Detachment Commander's Office.
Yu Yuan and the others listened to Zhou Qianxin's report, and they also lost their minds for a moment.
A few seconds later, Yu Chen said with a little entanglement: "You mean, when Yan Yu was tied up and thrown into the Fujiang River, he was actually not dead."
"Hmm."
Zhou Qianxin bowed: "Ordinary people, even if they have a certain level of education, it is actually difficult to accurately judge clinical death, after all, medicine is a very professional discipline. ” "Including many colleagues in the detachment, judging whether a person is dead or not, they are still at a very layman's level of probing the nose and listening to the heartbeat, and if they are a little more professional, they may also feel the lower carotid pulse on the neck."
"But during the NDE, the breathing and heartbeat become so weak that it's hard to feel by touch alone.
What's more, even if the breathing and heartbeat stop, as long as the central nervous system has not died, it may not be irreversible, and it may be rescued by cardiopulmonary resuscitation, pacing, etc., which is the so-called suspended animation. ” So the gangsters misjudged Yan Hui's state of life and mistakenly thought that he was dead, so they decided to throw the body, which is actually normal.
Such cases, while uncommon, are not uncommon. ” Yu Chen smiled bitterly: "Hey, they have obviously been recruited, but now I see, I have to re-interrogate tomorrow morning, and I have to do a lot of repetitive work."
"What are you talking about," Yuan Youchong rolled his eyes: "In these years, criminal cases are a lifelong responsibility system, and it is good to be cautious, in this regard, you have to thank Xiao Zhou" "Well, I don't blame Xiao Zhou."
Yu Chen pursed his lips, stretched his waist and said: "Forget it, the facts of the case are quite clear, and it doesn't take much effort to try it again, that is, to go through the motions and re-determine the responsibilities they each bear." ” "It's a pity that such a young man is gone.
Hmph, these robbers are really hateful, they even want to take advantage of the mother's desire for the health of their children, and then use organs such as severed limbs and toes to defraud Ji Siying of a sum of money after Yan Fu's death."
Yuan Youchong also sighed: "It's also pitiful for Ji Siying, I actually ran into a scumbag like Yan Hongyu and put this on the table."
Zhou Qianxin said: "What I am more concerned about now is how the actions of Wei Qingqing and Wei Chuchu will be characterized, and what kind of punishment they will receive They can also be regarded as the fuse of this tragedy, and they can't only be characterized as juniors."
Yu Yuan and the two glanced at each other and were silent.
Seeing this, Zhou Qianxin sighed and closed her eyes: "Ji Siying is to Yan Hongyu, she should be the wife of the dregs."
"Poor friends should not be forgotten, and wives of bad chaff will not go to court.
Treacherous and negative men, as expected, few have a good end, "punishment and murder
.
" :